Why do we have disposable tools?
Amen to Toolmonger for pointing out the contrast between Stanley's ornate, antique screwdrivers and today's less inspiring options.
From TM: "As a tool, the plastic-handled driver will most likely see more action than the metal-handled work of art—but we’d love to have that choice."
I couldn't agree more. But I'm open to a dissenting opinion.
On one side, we have a product that's weathered decades because it's well-made, beautiful, and worth keeping. On the other, we have a plastic product that's just as functional, comparably durable, but ultimately disposable.
It's not just Stanley's fault—the misguided disposable materials mindset affects everything from the tools themselves to the structures they build.
Antique iron tool vs. cheap plastic handle. Row houses vs. strip malls. Which do you think will still be around decades from now?
And how has it happened that in the past few decades, this mentality has so pervaded our culture that it is now nearly impossible to find a tool that's built with any sense of permanence?
I mean, it's a screwdriver. It's not a cell phone. It will never be obsolete. I want one I want to keep.
If I'm overlooking some examples of exceptional design, let me know.
More:
A recent soapbox screed about power tools. Same gripe.
Our gallery of heirloom tools.
The informative, irritating Story of Stuff.
Posted by Harry Sawyers | Categories: Green Home, Hand Tools | Permalink
(2) Comments
Sheffield started selling a couple of 'antique' hand tools which I found on Amazon. I picked up a some knives and a multi-tool, and they have a 4 piece modern screwdriver set, and a modern flip out utility knife, all styled in wood and brass. Really they are cheaply made, but they are heavy and look great, and they really feel like you are using a tool rather than a toy. I keep them in the kitchen drawer for small DIY projects around the house. They are my favorites, even though I don't think they'd last long on the job.
Look up Sheffield WH58003 on Amazon, though they are double the price now of when I go them.
Well for one thing a screwdriver today is such a minuscule investment compared to 100 years ago. Today even the best screwdriver is what .00001% of I have no hard info to back it up, but I'd bet that 100 years ago it was a much more significant investment. Because of that people don't take as good care of them, and really don't care if they are going to last particularly well. Heck, I know the chances are that I'm going to lose even a poorly built screwdriver long before it actually breaks. Would you really want to pay 10 times as much for a screwdriver with a fancy metal handle, that doesn't actually work any better?
Course if you don't like the idea of ever buying a new one, just get a nice craftsman with their lifetime guarantee.